Are Small Firms Labour Constrained? Experimental Evidence from Ghana
Research Note
Published on 19 October 2017
Abstract
Firms in poor countries are much smaller than firms in rich countries, with the modal firm being a single person, the owner. Meanwhile, youth unemployment and underemployment are widespread. Understanding whether labour market frictions co-exist with capital and managerial skill constraints to limit firm growth is thus quite important. This project studies a program that randomly placed unemployed young people to work as apprentices with small firms in Ghana. Firms that were offered apprentices by the program experienced increases in both firm size and profits over the two years of our study window. These effects vary as a function of worker cognitive ability (unobserved by the firm owner), highlighting the potential role of screening in firms’ hiring decisions in our context. This screening interpretation echoes the widespread use of an entry fee mechanism to hire apprentices in our baseline labour market.
This project studies a randomized, large-scale unconditional cash transfer program in Kenya, and find a meaningful increase in revenues for enterprises in areas experiencing a greater volume of cash transfers.
A detailed survey of the Indian brick industry shows substantial productivity dispersion, attributable to both technology differences as well as within-technology efficiency variation.
In Ethiopia, Blattman, Dercon and Franklin (2019) randomly assign mostly female jobseekers to receive an industrial job offer or an unconditional cash transfer, meant to spur self-employment.
Hardy and McCasland (2021) report on an experiment that brings insights from the literature on demand-side determinants of technology adoption to the study of peer-to-peer diffusion.
A common concern with efforts to directly help some small businesses to grow is that their growth comes at the expense of their unassisted competitors.
Alfonsi, Bandiera, Bassi, Burgess, Rasul, Sulaiman and Vitali (2020) design a labor market experiment to compare demand- and supply-side policies to tackle youth unemployment, a key issue in low-income countries.
Bargaining over purchase prices with microenterprise owners in Ghana, Hardy et al. (2020) show that poorer sellers agree to significantly lower prices than wealthier peers.
